Best Gelato in Siesta Key

"Think big and colorful, and you’ll have the amazing scoops of ice cream at Big Olaf Creamery in Sarasota. Big Olaf Creamery has been around since 1982 making homemade ice cream and cones!. They have multiple locations that are all very family-friendly which is perfect for a birthday or meeting friends!"

"If you’re looking for a pick-me-up in the middle of the day or want to escape the hot sun, stop by Big Olaf Creamery. This hidden gem features homemade ice cream in waffle cones and any other sweet treat you might want!. They are located at 5208 Ocean Boulevard and are open Sunday through Thursday from 11 a.m."

"5208 Ocean Blvd., Sarasota; 941-349-9392; bigolafsiestakey.com. This is where children of all ages have been going for ice cream, made by local Amish experts since 1982. Mask up to order inside and then enjoy your treats at one of the many surrounding benches."

"Sweet treat enthusiasts will find the focus-on-the-basics approach at Big Olaf Creamery pleasing. It’s all about ice cream, pure and unique, and there’s plenty of it to go around. The rotating menu offers different seasonal delights."

"Culver’s® is a family-favorite restaurant known for cooked-to-order ButterBurgers, handcrafted Fresh Frozen Custard and Wisconsin Cheese Curds. Welcome to delicious®."

"Was looking forward to eating with my family before my flight home. So we stopped here because they offer gluten free options. Everyone got to eat but me..."

"This is the only DQ that I've seen that doesn't offer hamburgers. Be nice if they did. The malts are so ..."

"Made in Rome is in the smack-center of Siesta Key Village and it unequivocally offers the most authentic and legitimate Italian gelato on the island- and maybe even the state. It’s organic, as well, which means no hydrogenated fats, no preservatives, and no dyes or colorants. The spoons are also made of 100% recyclable corn fiber."

"There’s a trend happening now in ice cream that is scientifically-perfected for your satisfaction. It is nitrogen flash-frozen ice cream, and it’s a wonderful treat for visitors. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream welcomes visitors to a rush of fog and noise from the nitrogen-based freezes happening right on the spot."

"A staple in Bradenton for over 20 years, SweetBerries Frozen Custard & Eatery is the go-to place for a delicious frozen treat you won’t soon forget. Their custard is fresh-made at least two times a day. Using their secret recipe (which includes a bit of egg yolk) and a slow-churn method they create a dense, thick frozen dessert with a premium ice cream taste and far less fat."

"If I want to wait in a drive through that long next time, I'll head over to chik fil a More reviews"