Winter Vacation Rentals & Cabin Rentals in Fire Island, NY

Compare 1,546 available, short term beachfront holiday vacation home properties, starts from $54

Navigate forward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Navigate backward to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Find the best vacation rental

ACCOMMODATION TYPES

Monthly & Short Term Winter Vacation Rentals in Fire Island, NY: Top Deals

Garden City Hotel
Garden City Hotel
Garden City Hotel
Garden City Hotel
Garden City Hotel
Garden City Hotel
Garden City Hotel
Garden City Hotel
4.6 (205 reviews)
Garden City Hotel
Hotel
$167 /night
View deal
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
4.3 (130 reviews)
Courtyard by Marriott Westbury Long Island
Hotel
$122 /night
View deal
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
4.3 (71 reviews)
Courtyard Republic Airport Long Island/Farmingdale
Hotel
$143 /night
View deal
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
4.3 (508 reviews)
Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island
Hotel
$127 /night
View deal
Cozy Suite near JFK
Cozy Suite near JFK
Cozy Suite near JFK
Cozy Suite near JFK
Cozy Suite near JFK
Cozy Suite near JFK
Cozy Suite near JFK
4.5 (4 reviews)
Cozy Suite near JFK
Hotel
$80 /night
View deal
The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay House
The Ocean Bay House
4.7 (79 reviews)
The Ocean Bay House
House
$150 /night
View deal
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
4.2 (141 reviews)
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott New York Queens/Fresh Meadows
Hotel
$116 /night
View deal
Holiday Inn Express - Jamaica - JFK AirTrain - NYC
Holiday Inn Express - Jamaica - JFK AirTrain - NYC
Holiday Inn Express - Jamaica - JFK AirTrain - NYC
Holiday Inn Express - Jamaica - JFK AirTrain - NYC
Holiday Inn Express - Jamaica - JFK AirTrain - NYC
Holiday Inn Express - Jamaica - JFK AirTrain - NYC
4.0 (12 reviews)
Holiday Inn Express - Jamaica - JFK AirTrain - NYC
Hotel
$110 /night
View deal
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
4.4 (117 reviews)
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
Hotel
$127 /night
View deal
Search all

Similar Inspirational Vacation Rental Destinations

Which Price Range Is Considered As A Good Deal in Fire Island, NY Area?
Vacation House & Apartment Rental Price Information in Fire Island, NY
+
The graph shows the percentages of vacation homes in each price bucket. Fire Island has the largest percentage (43.08%) of homes in $500+ price range.
$0 to 50
$0 to 50
$50 to 100
$50 to 100
$100 to 150
$100 to 150
$150 to 200
$150 to 200
$200 to 250
$200 to 250
$250 to 300
$250 to 300
$300 to 350
$300 to 350
$350 to 400
$350 to 400
$400 to 450
$400 to 450
$450 to 500
$450 to 500
$500 +
$500 +
What are the best activities, communities or places of interest for snowbirds in Fire Island, NY?
Top 3 Snowbird-Friendly Places in Fire Island, NY
+
Fire Island is an ideal destination for snowbirds looking to enjoy a peaceful and laid-back atmosphere. The island offers plenty of outdoor activities such as swimming, fishing, boating, and bird watching. There are also many lovely beaches, restaurants, and shops that provide a relaxing environment for seniors. Proximity to healthcare is easily accessible with two medical centers located on the east end of the island.

  • Fire Island Lighthouse

    The Fire Island Lighthouse is a great spot for snowbirds to explore the beautiful views of the Great South Bay and the Atlantic Ocean. It has a boardwalk where seniors can take leisurely strolls while appreciating the scenery.

  • Sunken Forest

    The Sunken Forest is a maritime forest located at the William Floyd Estate. Here, snowbirds can explore nature trails surrounded by trees and shrubs. Seniors will find it enjoyable to observe the wildlife here.

  • Davis Park Ferry

    The Davis Park Ferry provides seniors with a convenient way to get around Fire Island. This ferry ride offers beautiful views of the bay and is a great opportunity for snowbirds to experience the island’s vibrant culture.

How Many Accommodations Are Pets Allowed in Fire Island, NY?
Pets Allowed vs Not Allowed in Fire Island, NY
+
25.36% of vacation homes in Fire Island are pet friendly. Either you bring your loved pets on vacation or you have pet allergies, make sure to select the homes by applying the right filters.
Where Should We Visit in Fire Island, NY Area?
Destinations To Visit During the Winter in Fire Island, NY
+
Which Airports Should I Choose To Get To Fire Island, NY?
Airports Options in Fire Island, NY
+

Other Vacation Rentals Ideas

* The displayed nightly rate may be estimated based on a future travel date. Narrow down your search with checkin and checkout dates to see the exact price.
See all offers