Find the best vacation rental

ACCOMMODATION TYPES

Save Up To 80%

Airbnb, Vacation rentals and hotel deals in Plum Island, NY

9.8 (44 reviews)
Peaceful and Private Shelter Island Getaway
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$275 /night*
View deal
9.7 (39 reviews)
The Menhaden Hotel
Hotel · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$282 /night
View deal
8.9 (51 reviews)
American Beech Hotel
Hotel · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$303 /night
View deal
9.8 (68 reviews)
First Floor 1905 Victorian home in the heart of Greenport Village
Apartment · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$375 /night*
View deal
8.0 (184 reviews)
Sound View Greenport
Hotel · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$186 /night
View deal
Charming Old Saybrook Cottage < 1 Mi to Beach
Cottage · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$396 /night
View deal
10 (145 reviews)
Private & Spacious Five Room Suite<br>Steps To Bay Beach and walk to Village.
Apartment · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$433 /night*
View deal
9.8 (55 reviews)
Cottage on Beach front Estate
Cottage · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$300 /night*
View deal
8.8 (12 reviews)
Quaint Coastal Cottage in Beautiful White Sands Beach
Cottage · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$236 /night*
View deal
9.3 (3 reviews)
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
B & B · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$369 /night
View deal
10 (24 reviews)
Gracious, Airy New London Cottage, Steps from Private Beach
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$375 /night*
View deal
9.8 (9 reviews)
Spacious Beach House walking distance to the beach
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$350 /night*
View deal
9.6 (6 reviews)
Sleek Shelter Island With Pool, Preserve And Water Rights:
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$500 /night*
View deal
Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
Hotel · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$304 /night
View deal
9.8 (18 reviews)
Storybook Beautiful 3-Bedroom Cape
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$350 /night*
View deal
9.8 (74 reviews)
Walk to the beach at Black Point, Niantic, Ct.
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$133 /night*
View deal
9.6 (139 reviews)
Inn at Harbor Hill Marina
B & B · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$172 /night
View deal
9.6 (44 reviews)
5BR Charming Beach House with PRIVATE beaches in beautiful Neptune Park!
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$430 /night*
View deal
10 (16 reviews)
POOL + Private Beach near Greenport!
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$600 /night*
View deal
ZEY HOTEL
B & B · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$400 /night
View deal

Airbnb, Holiday Beachfront House with Air Conditioning in Plum Island, NY

9.3 (3 reviews)
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
B & B · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$369 /night
View deal
9.6 (139 reviews)
Inn at Harbor Hill Marina
B & B · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$172 /night
View deal
9.6 (37 reviews)
East Hampton Art House Bed and Breakfast
B & B · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$457 /night
View deal
What Are The Well Liked Rental Amenities in Plum Island, NY?
Amenity Info in Plum Island, NY
+
There are in total of 15 rental amenities in Plum Island, shown above with the property numbers. In Plum Island, 2375 rentals offer Internet or Wifi, 2269 rentals offer No Smoking, 2240 rentals offer TV. So, if you need Internet or Wifi during your vacation, use the Internet or Wifi filter to compare these properties. Two amenities that are not typical are Hot Tub, Pets Friendly.

What is the Best Time to Rent a Cheap Vacation Rental in Plum Island, NY?

Tips to Rent Vacation Rentals (Stay for a Week) for Cheapest Price in Plum Island, NY

Low Season
February
Most affordable month to stay
$75
Average rate of the cheapest vacation rentals option in low season month
High Season
July
Peak month to stay
$270
Average rate of the cheapest stay option in high season month
$270
Jul
$238
Aug
$95
Sep
$95
Oct
$95
Nov
$95
Dec
$95
Jan
$75
Feb
$75
Mar
$75
Apr
$75
May
$75
Jun
$225
Sun
$238
Mon
$238
Tue
$270
Wed
$270
Thu
$270
Fri
$270
Sat
Cheapest day of week
Sunday
Vacation rentals price normally the lowest on this day
$225
is the cheapest nightly rate for vacation rentals on this day
Highest day of week
Wednesday
Most expansive day to book a vacation rentals
$270
is the highest nightly rate for vacation rentals on this day
How Does The Vacation Home Rental Price Look Like in Plum Island, NY?
Vacation Rentals Price Information in Plum Island, NY
+
The graph shows the percentages of vacation homes in each price bucket. Plum Island has the largest percentage (45.16%) of homes in $500+ price range.
$0 to 50
$0 to 50
$50 to 100
$50 to 100
$100 to 150
$100 to 150
$150 to 200
$150 to 200
$200 to 250
$200 to 250
$250 to 300
$250 to 300
$300 to 350
$300 to 350
$350 to 400
$350 to 400
$400 to 450
$400 to 450
$450 to 500
$450 to 500
$500 +
$500 +
What Are The Popular Property Types in Plum Island, NY?
Vacation Rental Property Types in Plum Island, NY
+
In Plum Island, 79.77% of listings are House, which is the most popular accommodation out of 21 total accommodation types. Avg price per night for House is around $536. And the most searched amenities for House accommodation is Hot Tub.The least popular accommodation in Plum Island is Cabin rentals
How Many Rental Accommodations Are Pets Friendly in Plum Island, NY?
Percentage of Pet Friendly Vacation Rentals in Plum Island, NY
+
31.25% of vacation homes in Plum Island are pet friendly. If you have pet allergies, make sure to check the home property and see whether it is a pet-friendly vacation home or not.
Which Airports Should I Choose To Get To Plum Island, NY?
Suggested Airports in Plum Island, NY
+

Airbnb, Holiday Beachfront House with Fireplace in Plum Island, NY

9.8 (35 reviews)
NEWLY RENOVATED WITH POOL, HOT TUB, AND FIREPLACE!
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$300 /night*
View deal
10 (2 reviews)
Chic Shelter Island Home, Pool and Gardens
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$1,500 /night*
View deal
9.8 (48 reviews)
Beautiful Renovated Beachfront Home
Holiday home · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$650 /night*
View deal

Airbnb, Vacation Rentals, Cottage with Full Kitchen, and Other Rental Options in Plum Island, NY

9.8 (55 reviews)
Cottage on Beach front Estate
Cottage · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$300 /night*
View deal
10 (9 reviews)
Beach Cottage
Cottage · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$200 /night*
View deal
9.8 (69 reviews)
'The Gate House' on Beach front Estate Walk to Village
Cottage · 2 Guests · 1 Bedroom
$242 /night*
View deal
* The displayed nightly rate may be estimated based on a future travel date. Narrow down your search with checkin and checkout dates to see the exact price.
See all offers