Top Best Italian Restaurants in Sanibel Island

"Island Pizza Company is a quaint and colorful “FAMILY” owned restaurant located conveniently on Sanibel Island, with over 8 years of experience. We specialize in home cooked Italian cuisine. With an aroma of fresh cut garlic and basil filling the air, you enter an atmosphere that will make you feel right at home."

"We never leave the island without at least getting take out at Island Pizza for an evening. Their pizza always hits the spot, I recommend grabbing a make your own 6-pack at Bailey’s to go with the meal 🙂. 1619 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island, FL."

"My husband had Alfredo with sliced sausage and I had the asparagus and shrimp (Can't remember the exact name.). Both meals were incredible. The service was phenomenal."

"Jerry’s Café is open seven days a week for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy fresh-made breakfast pastries, signature sandwiches (check out our grouper!), delicious dinner entrees, and fabulous desserts – like our fan-favorite Key Lime Pie – all while enjoying our tropical bird habitat. In addition to our full menu we offer a build-your-own gourmet salad and sandwich bar, exciting daily specials, a fantastic full menu, and a wide assortment of beer and wine."

"Finally, Jerry’s Foods is your one-stop-shop not only for ice cream but also for groceries, household items, and everything else you’ll need for a great stay on the island. If you’ve got a favorite national brand of ice cream that you usually pick up from your freezer section, you can find it right here and take it back to your rental!. You can also stock your kitchen with selections from their Fish Market, Butcher Shop, full-service deli, and Bake Shop."

"Say hello to the macaws on the porch as you head in to pick up some essentials at Jerry’s Foods. Jerry’s started as a butcher shop, so this is probably the best place to pick up some items for a cookout night at your condo. Also on your menu should be the Key lime pie, reported to be the best in the world — but I think there are several other destinations on Sanibel that might dispute that claim!"

"For some truly delicious and unique coffee-style beverages, we suggest taking a stroll to Sanibel Bean. They have a relaxing atmosphere to enjoy your beverage and are near many quaint little shops and boutiques. They have an extensive menu of delicious drinks to choose from and many café style treats and sammies!"

"Open Sunday - Thursday 7:00am to 2:00pm, Friday - Saturday 7:00am to 3:00pm. If it’s a quick cup-a-Joe to go or coffee drink and pastry you’re after, the Sanibel Bean is the best stop on Sanibel Island. They also serve breakfast all day."

"Popular local hangout with an extensive cafe menu of quick, cheap eats that are surprisingly tasty and prepared with love. The staff are as friendly as they come."

"There are often lines on the weekend to get a table in this small, strip mall eatery. The gym, located a few doors down, does little to deter diners from indulging on breakfast specialties like French toast, pancakes, corned beef, and biscuits and gravy. If you're an omelet lover, you'll be giddy at the gourmet choices here like crab and brie, or filet mignon."

"CRaVE is one of the locally owned restaurants in Fort Myers that opened in 2007. CRaVE is known for using the freshest ingredients on their menu in addition to making bread homemade and smoking and curing all their own meats and sausages. The menu is separated into CRaVE salads, sandwiches and classics."

"Bayside Seafood Grill & Bar offers guests the chance to dine at one of three, very distinct, settings. On the sidewalk level, you’ll find the Cafe, a great spot for sandwiches, salads and light entrees throughout the day. Venture a little higher, and you’ll land on The Grill, an elegant venue serving up a fine line in sophisticated, cutting edge seafood, meats, and pasta (not to mention a very decent range of cocktails)."

"Bayside Seafood Grill & Bar has Brunch every Sunday from 11:00am-2:00pm. The Bayside website has a full listing of their brunch menu (https://www.baysideseafoodgrillandbar.com/menu/) but we will give you an exciting sneak peek. The Brunch menu has a full selection of starters, salads, sandwiches, and specialty items."

"A post shared by Bayside Seafood Grill and Bar (@baysidenaples) on Dec 29, 2018 at 3:47pm PST. Bayside Seafood Grill & Bar is a local favorite when it comes to seafood dining!. The classic seafood cuisines are remarkable."

"This is a museum as well a performing arts center in Pelican Bay. The purpose of this museum was to awaken the love for colors and arts. It is basically a visual arts museum which focuses a lot on the works of modern and contemporary artists."