Top Best American Restaurants in North Captiva Island

"Plates full of oysters, shrimp baskets, bbq-soaked ribs, thick-cut French fries, and so much more line up the tables at this bar and restaurant. Order a drink in a very Florida mason jar. Mojitos and daiquiris are the two most popular, but there’s a full rum bar for you to let loose."

"Hand-made ravioli stuffed with sweet lobster or local vegetables; Gulf grouper seared till the skin crisps and then set atop a polenta cake that's comforting and faintly sweet. The servers are equally excellent, well-versed on wine pairings and the ins and outs of this stellar, ever-changing menu. The dining room is dark, quiet and classy, with all the trimmings (white table cloths, linen napkins, a live pianist) you'd expect in fine dining."

"The original Fish House opened in Bonita Springs, Florida in 1994. The Sanibel Island location has been open since 2012. Fish House is very proud of the many Taste of the Islands Awards it has received."

"Cip’s Place is a good compromise option when you want to enjoy a nice meal in a casual environment that works for your kids. This restaurant has a strong connection to the island’s history, with murals of important Sanibel Island residents and scrapbooks your kids can look through while waiting for their food. Opt for the outdoor seating option to enjoy the fresh island air."

"South Beach Grille specializes in traditional, American cuisine with a creative flair. Fine, yet casual dining, exceptional food and high-quality service is you can expect when you dine at South Beach Grille. You’ll enjoy our warm, colorful decor, delicious food with exquisite presentation, mouthwatering desserts, specialty cocktails, coffee drinks and more."

"Exquisite presentation and fresh local ingredients are the two main factors when you order your meal at South Beach Grille. Located in the Santini Marina Plaza Shops on Estero Blvd, this fine dining restaurant boasts a diverse menu with something for everyone, but their seafood and steak get the best reviews."

"Have a great cocktail or cool beer several days a week and at the same time enjoy great live performances. Friends of funk, soul and jazz will get their money’s worth at the Space 39. Also for private parties, for example, for birthday celebrations, this location is the ideal place."

"Make your way to this ‘Sanctuary of Art’ and take in the rotating exhibit comprised of talented local artists. The season’s schedule features mediums such as ceramic sculpture, wood carving, oil painting, drawing, photography, and glass. Watson MacRae Gallery is driven by the notion that art heals, and invites you to visit and experience the unique spirit of the gallery."

"Referred to as a Sanctuary of Art, the Watson MacRae Gallery on Sanibel features exhibits in 2- and 3-dimensional mediums by both national and regional artists. The gallery will begin its 12th season in November 2019 and has shown more than 50 exhibitions. Exhibits are shown during the winter season (November through April) and the summer (April through October)."

"The most secluded of our 7 Dreamy Beaches, Bowman’s Beach Sanibel has everything a beach lover could want — soft white sand on a nice wide beach in a rustic natural environment, beautiful wildlife sightings from the boardwalk, changing rooms, and restrooms. It’s not plush but that’s kind of the point — Sanibel’s natural beauty is on full display. Located toward the west end of the island, Bowman’s Beach has grown in popularity but it’s still private and secluded."

"There’s no shortage of beautiful beaches on Sanibel Island, but if you’re looking for one that is less crowded but with some amenities, Bowman’s Beach is the best option. This stretch of soft, white sand is great for children and a popular option for anyone seeking unique shells. Other popular activities include swimming, windsurfing, and sailing, and on-site amenities include picnic areas with BBQ grills, bathrooms with showers, and a playground."

"Bowman’s Beach is one of many beaches on Sanibel Island, and on the western portion of the island.It’s a protected site, with no developments going on, which leaves a pure and natural landscape to enjoy for all. The only vegetation around is the natural one that grows, which opens up the scenery. The immensity of the sky and the sea together offer vast and breathtaking views in all directions that work together to draw you in."

"Featuring a large parking area, along with restrooms and public showers, Tarpon Beach is another picturesque Sanibel Island spot to spend a day. It's found at the southern end of Tarpon Bay Road, around halfway across the island itself. It's a simple beach that stretches out a good distance in both directions, offering a lot of space for everyone to enjoy."

"For a beach that is central and safe, you want Tarpon Bay Beach. There are places that are perfectly safe for swimming here and it’s one of the better populated beaches in the area. The water moves fast, and the resorts and rentals are well-placed for a day of fun at the beach."

"My husband had Alfredo with sliced sausage and I had the asparagus and shrimp (Can't remember the exact name.). Both meals were incredible. The service was phenomenal."

"When chef-owner AJ Black is in the kitchen, this cozy-yet-high-end Italian restaurant is hard to beat. Black, who's cooked at the James Beard House in Manhattan, is the real deal. At Il Tesoro he's crafted a menu that can be as classic (spaghetti Carbonara, chicken saltimbocca) or modern (scallops with a balsamic and blood-orange reduction) as you like."