Find the best vacation rental

ACCOMMODATION TYPES

Cheap Airbnb in Shelter Island, NY: Top Deals

Private Spacious Family-Friendly Sag Harbor House w/ Pool; Close to Beach
Guest Suite Β· 10 Guests Β· 5 Bedrooms
$1497 /night*
View deal
5.0 (4 reviews)
Secluded Hamptons Cottage
Guest Suite Β· 4 Guests Β· 2 Bedrooms
$648 /night*
View deal
🌟 Walk to the village ❀ of Greenport
Guest Suite Β· 6 Guests Β· 3 Bedrooms
$654 /night*
View deal
4.8 (23 reviews)
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast
Bed And Breakfast
$370 /night
View deal
private water view home, beach access, heated pool
Guest Suite Β· 6 Guests Β· 4 Bedrooms
$2127 /night*
View deal
5.0 (2 reviews)
Sag Harbor beach house with heated pool
Guest Suite Β· 2 Guests Β· 3 Bedrooms
$1413 /night*
View deal
Stunning 3 BR / 2.5 Bath New Construction Home in East Hampton w/ In Ground Pool
Guest Suite Β· 10 Guests Β· 3 Bedrooms
$1438 /night*
View deal
5.0 (1 review)
Beautiful, fully updated, Spacious East Hampton home minutes from town and beach
Guest Suite Β· 14 Guests Β· 5 Bedrooms
$2197 /night*
View deal
5.0 (54 reviews)
Relax to a 5-Star Vineyard View Steps from the Beach and a Short Walk to Town
Guest Suite Β· 2 Guests Β· 4 Bedrooms
$592 /night*
View deal

Similar Inspirational Vacation Rental Destinations

Which Price Range Is Considered As A Good Deal in Shelter Island, NY Area?
Vacation House & Cottage Rental Price Information in Shelter Island, NY
+
The graph shows the percentages of vacation homes in each price bucket. Shelter Island has the largest percentage (55.68%) of homes in $500+ price range.
$0 to 50
$0 to 50
$50 to 100
$50 to 100
$100 to 150
$100 to 150
$150 to 200
$150 to 200
$200 to 250
$200 to 250
$250 to 300
$250 to 300
$300 to 350
$300 to 350
$350 to 400
$350 to 400
$400 to 450
$400 to 450
$450 to 500
$450 to 500
$500 +
$500 +
How Many Accommodations Are Pets Allowed in Shelter Island, NY?
Percentage of Pet Friendly Rental Properties in Shelter Island, NY
+
34.65% of vacation homes in Shelter Island are pet friendly. Make sure you select the pet friendly home filter when you are going to bring your pet(s) for the upcoming vacation.
What are the Airports in Shelter Island, NY?
Suggested Airports in Shelter Island, NY
+

Here are the airports that located near Shelter Island:

Other Vacation Rentals Ideas

* The displayed nightly rate may be estimated based on a future travel date. Narrow down your search with checkin and checkout dates to see the exact price.
See all offers